Which might you select: free cash you get to maintain, or cash it’s worthwhile to pay again with curiosity?

That was the simple resolution some small companies received to make when California rolled out two monetary help applications across the similar time in late 2020, in keeping with a latest report from the Little Hoover Fee, an impartial oversight company.

In response to companies battling the pandemic, Gov. Gavin Newsom unveiled a small enterprise mortgage program referred to as the California Rebuilding Fund in late November 2020.

A few week later, Newsom mentioned the state would additionally distribute grants to small companies impacted by the pandemic.

“Mortgage funds can’t compete with free cash,” mentioned Scott Wu, government director of California’s IBank, a financing company inside the Governor’s Workplace of Enterprise and Financial Growth, which supplied the preliminary money for the fund.

On high of grants from the state, forgivable Paycheck Safety Program loans had been out there from the federal authorities. So, the IBank and the enterprise teams it was working with took a step again from advertising the mortgage program, Wu mentioned.

Demand for the loans was “a lot decrease” than anticipated, he mentioned. On the outset, architects of the mortgage fund anticipated it would attain a dimension of between $250 million and $500 million. Thus far it’s raised simply $114 million, mentioned Beth Bafford, vp at Calvert Influence Capital, which organized the fund.

However, mentioned Wu, there was a necessity for each sorts of aid. The grants ranged from $5,000-$25,000, whereas the loans are capped at $100,000.

The Rebuilding Fund has distributed about $71 million in loans to about 1,200 companies in California, the overwhelming majority of which have gone to companies with 10 or fewer staff, in keeping with the report.

San Francisco surpasses everybody else

Companies throughout the state didn’t make the most of this system equally. In 19 counties, no one acquired a mortgage, in keeping with the report. In a number of counties, only one or two companies received one. All companies that accomplished functions and met eligibility and credit score necessities acquired the mortgage, mentioned Bafford.

Two-hundred-two loans totaling about $15 million went to companies in San Francisco County, in keeping with the report. Companies in that county acquired 17% of the entire funds distributed to date, regardless of being dwelling to 2% of Californians.

That’s as a result of San Francisco constructed on high of the state’s program, investing $four million of its personal cash, $2 million of which went to paying down curiosity. That enabled the town to supply zero curiosity loans to companies, mentioned Kate Sofis, director of the town’s Workplace of Financial and Workforce Growth.

With out the zero curiosity loans, far fewer companies would have made use of the fund, Sofis mentioned. And, she mentioned, the town plans to speculate one other $1 million of its personal cash into this system.

Plenty of different municipalities and counties determined to run their very own grant applications for small companies as a substitute, mentioned Bafford.

Fresno, for instance, arrange its personal grant program, mentioned Tate Hill, government director of Entry Plus Capital, a small enterprise mortgage fund that serves Central California. One other issue, Hill mentioned, is that some areas of California don’t have as many monetary establishments devoted to serving low-income communities, which assist run mortgage applications, however the Bay Space has many.

Companies within the 13 counties that make up the Central Valley acquired a mixed 53 loans totaling about $three million, compared to San Francisco county’s 202, in keeping with the report.

“We now have among the poorest communities in all the state,” mentioned Wealthy Mostert, the director of the Valley Group Small Enterprise Growth Middle, which serves Fresno, Tulare, Madera, and Kings counties.

San Francisco’s success didn’t detract from the flexibility of companies in different counties to get loans, mentioned Bafford. The town’s program attracted extra non-public funding to the fund, she mentioned, and it’s not as disproportionate as it might seem primarily based on inhabitants, given the excessive density of companies in San Francisco.

Loans from the fund might be out there by way of November 2022, mentioned Bafford. She’s discussing with the state “what the long run holds past that.”

###

CalMatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media enterprise explaining California insurance policies and politics.